Real Homemade American Bacon

by Nick Kindelsperger on July 2, 2008

homemadeamericanbacon01

A couple of Fridays ago, I showed up at my sister's house with a big hunk of pork belly, a pork butt, and some hickory sawdust, and for the next 8 hours I smoked meat.  I thought it would be a carefree time and a big improvement over the first time I tried to smoke meat.  I dreamed of watching the smoke pour out the side of that grill, while taking slow, steady drinks of a cold beer and listening to Hank Williams.  But my experiments don't always go as planned.  The first hour was chaotic.  I couldn't get the smoke to come and tried various ridiculous steps to figure something out.  But once it came, as the above picture does attest, it billowed.  I could do nothing but sit and stare at the smoke.  The moment was among the most satisfying experiences I have ever had. 

I was spurred to smoke by a great barbecue book called Peace, Love, & Barbecue by Mike Mills and Amy Mills Tunnicliffe.  Their book had a recipe for the perfect pulled pork, which I'll write about that later.  But with the smoke pouring out, I thought I would tackle bacon again.  I needed to right a few wrongs. 

My previous attempt wasn't necessarily a disaster, it just turned out differently than I had wanted.  That River Cottage approved bacon was heavily salted and perfect for stews, big pots of beans, and other hearty dishes.  But I wanted breakfast bacon.  I wanted a maple syrup tinge and I wanted smoke.  I realized I'd need to hunker down and really figure how to do this right. 

homemadeamericanbacon02

First, I needed to find some pork belly with its skin still firmly on. My previous attempt removed it, along with a lot of precious fat directly underneath.  My bacon didn't have nearly enough fat on it to fry up, so instead cooking up beautifully in a pan, it burned.  My local butcher wouldn't sell me a piece with the skin on unless I bought 10 pounds, a fact I still find ridiculous.  A commenter pointed out that Asian Markets tend to sell pork belly with the skin still on.  The only Asian market I could find was 161 in Northern Columbus, which sat across the street from a Whole Foods, which for some insane reason can't even sell pork belly.  The Asian market had it, though not in as big a pieces as I would have liked.  But no matter, I just decided to buy two smaller hunks equaling about 3 pounds and got to business.

homemadeamericanbacon03

Second, I needed pink salt.  Blake talked highly about it, but I hesitated.  I couldn't find it at any specialty store in Columbus, including those that made their own sausages.  So I bit the bullet and ordered a large bag, which Blake assured me would "last for a long, long time".  He's right.  The pink salt (which is actually pink in color) is only used a teaspoon or so at a time.  Its traditional use was to help prevent botulism, but in this day and age of refrigeration its biggest draw is that it lends the meat a rosy hue and an unmistakable cured taste.  My bacon would look right.

homemadeamericanbacon04

Third, I needed a more appropriate cure.  My previous attempt was too savory.  Like I mentioned earlier, I wanted bacon that tasted like good American bacon with loads of maple syrup.    

I found this cure in Michael Ruhlman's Charcuterie. 

The cure:

  • 2 ounces kosher salt
  • 2 teaspoons pink salt
  • 1/4 cup brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup maple syrup
homemadeamericanbacon05

I mixed the cure together, and then rubbed the cure all over the pieces of pork belly.  I then placed them in a tightly fitting plastic bag.  Ruhlman said the cure would release some water in the pork creating a brine, so it was important that things were nice and snug. 

homemadeamericanbacon06

I cured the meat for 7 days, turning it over every other day.  On the seventh day, I removed the pork bellies, washed them off, and dried them for a day on a metal rack in the fridge.

homemadeamericanbacon07

Forth, I would need to smoke my bacon.  Smoke, as I've come to learn from Mike Mills, is all about flavor.  From the same company that I got the pink salt I ordered some hickory sawdust.  All I needed was a grill.  And without really consulting my sister, I decided to spend a whole day using her grill to make bacon.  I hoped she wouldn't care. 

homemadeamericanbacon08

The cooking process has two components.  The heat, which needed to hover around 200 degrees for about 3 hours, would be supplied by the gas grill.  I found that if I turned one of the three burners on low and closed the lid I'd get just about 200 degrees.  I regulated it by opening the hood if the temperature got too high.

The flavor would come from the hickory sawdust, which I had prepped by soaking in water for 30 minutes.  All I would need to do now was get the chips smoking by heating them.  Easier said than done. It wasn't until I opened up my sister's gas grill that I realized I could just toss the wood on top of the flame like I had on a charcoal grill.  I'd have to contain the sawdust somewhere. 

homemadeamericanbacon09

After some quick online consultation, I realized I could sprinkle some sawdust in a metal pan, cover it with foil, and then poke some holes in top to let the smoke pour out.  I set the tray over the burner.  I knew it would take some time, but after nearly 30 minutes without any smoke I started to panic.  My bacon was cooking this whole time and hadn't gotten any good smoke flavor.

homemadeamericanbacon10

So I did what any normal person would do and went to the corner store and bought some charcoal.  I doused the briquettes in lighter fluid, lit them out by the driveway, and once properly ashed over, I tossed them in the metal pan with the hickory sawdust and set that try in the gas grill.  I expected instantaneous combustion and for glorious smoke to instantly pour out.  But nothing. I doused it in more lighter fluid, tossed in a couple matches, and waited.  Still no smoke.  What could I possibly do?

Without the smoke I could have done this in the oven.  The low heat source wasn't providing much flavor, and a low oven would have done just as well.  I went back upstairs and looked at the techniques to get the sawdust smoking.  Nearly every said to do it the way I had first attempted.  I figured maybe I wasn't giving it enough heat.  So I dumped out the charcoal on the car patio, put new sawdust in the pan, covered it with aluminum foil, poked some holes, removed the metal grate, and set the tray right on top of the burner.  But this time over high heat.

homemadeamericanbacon11

Sure enough, after about 15 minutes the smoke came.

homemadeamericanbacon12

The smoke lasted for about 30 minutes.  To keep a constant flow of smoke, I had one tray over the high heat smoking away and then another tray beside it.  That other tray wouldn't begin to smoke until it was over high, but it seemed to have a leg up on a cold tray, which would have taken at least 15 minutes to start smoking.   

homemadeamericanbacon13

It took about 3 hours to get the bacon up to an internal temperature of 150 degrees.  Then I removed it from the grill and let it cool for 30 minutes or so. 

homemadeamericanbacon14

Though the skin helped make great bacon, it did need to be removed.  I took a long knife and slowly sliced as closely between the fat and skin as I could.  I wanted as much of the fat to stay as possible. 

homemadeamericanbacon15

It certainly looked good -don't you just wanted to take a big bite of that?- but not much like the bacon I had wanted.   

homemadeamericanbacon16

But once I sliced in, I realized that only the outside had the cooked appearance.  The inside looked exactly like regular bacon.

homemadeamericanbacon17

It was a lot harder to slice off uniform pieces of bacon than I had imagined.  But I finally did get a few pieces that, while small, did look like bacon. 

homemadeamericanbacon18

Ah bacon...  It took awhile, but like I mentioned earlier, it's unbelievably satisfying work.  And since it looks like regular bacon, I've been able to share this experience with other people.  I mean, who is going to turn down bacon?  But this bacon is different than the store bought kind.  The cure is vivid and clean, and the overall flavor is more pronounced.  Certainly not the easiest thing I've done, but I think completely worth it.

 

  • Share/Bookmark

{ 19 comments… read them below or add one }

Chocolatesa March 25, 2009 at 5:15 pm

You can make your own smoker for less than $50 here http://www.cruftbox.com/cruft/docs/elecsmoker.html
And here's another page on how to make your own bacon if you need more tips/tricks/recipes http://www.bsbrewing.com/blog/?p=261

Helen July 2, 2008 at 10:56 am

That looks absolutely beautiful. Now I'm craving bacon!

meghan July 2, 2008 at 11:00 am

I'm so impressed! Nice job!

ntsc The Art of The Pig July 2, 2008 at 11:31 am

Very nice looking. I've done that bacon, but baked not smoked it. Think this is the weekend to get the two bellys out to cure. One maple, one savory; both smoked.

JD July 2, 2008 at 12:06 pm

That looks extremely delicious. Good to know that you found a pork belly purveyor in Columbus. Did you try The Anderson's? Sometimes they can special-order things. (I still need to get veal bones for demi-glace…)

One tip on slicing – it's easier to slice big slabs of meat into thin, uniform pieces if you put them in the freezer for a bit. Not enough to throughly freeze, but just let them chill and firm up a bit.

Sir Cooksalot July 2, 2008 at 4:22 pm

May I suggest that at some point you guys post a booklist of the cook books you use for this site? I'd be very helpful for me around Christmas time and my birthday.

KrisK July 2, 2008 at 9:29 pm

I had the privilege of sampling a couple of slices of this fine Real Homemade American Bacon and can testify that it is really fine. Very tender and flavorful. Wonderful with eggs, OJ and milk.

RobinSue July 3, 2008 at 10:06 am

I am continually impressed with your ambitious undertakings. The bacon looks wonderful, just wish I could smell it! I enjoy it when my bother smokes his meats and I have a small stove top smoker but never the same as the real deal like my bro. Does the pink salt contain nitrates and nitrites, is that the cure part of the process? Keep up the great blog, I am enjoying it.

bristlesage July 4, 2008 at 10:13 am

Not that it sounds like you'll ever need to buy more, but if you do, you can get pink salt in more reasonable quantities at The Spice House. Paulina Meat Market sells this product, too, and if you've never been to Paulina, oh, man, you're in for a treat.

Your bacon looks divine. I'll have to see if I can convince my friends with a smoker to allow us to use it!

Nellie and Richard July 7, 2008 at 1:49 pm

We smoke ALL our own meat.

You need to be patient, that's for sure.
Your sawdust would surely have started smoking without all that dithering. Plus 30 minutes doesn't seem like long enough.

Anyway, keep trying. You'll learn by trial and error but it will be worth it.

S for Kitchen Confit July 7, 2008 at 11:19 pm

Gotta love bacon!

Traci @ Soup of The Day July 8, 2008 at 1:55 am

THIS I will definitely try. Thanks for the lovely step-by-step tutorial!

c-bus July 8, 2008 at 1:06 pm

There are a few other Asian markets in town. The Crestview market is on N. High and Crestview Rd(close to Clintonville) just North of the Giant Eagle, on the East side of the street. There is also one I haven't been to on Bethel in one of the shopping centers on the left side of the road.

Phil July 11, 2008 at 6:42 am

Very Nice. Here are some pictures of one of my attempts at making bacon.

http://www.takethecannolis.com/?itemid=10

That was last year, but I am still doing it and got a real smoker this year. I order my pork belly from Niman Ranch. Latino markets carry it sometimes too.

Greg Stephens July 11, 2008 at 1:12 pm

Dude you need a Big Green Egg bad!

daniel July 11, 2008 at 2:13 pm

wow, that looks so good!

cyber_rigger July 11, 2008 at 2:14 pm

For good smoke try oak bark from an old log or a dead tree. It usually comes off in big chunks.

You usually don't even have to soak it.

Just lay it on top of the smoldering coals.

I find it easier to regulate.

Todd Hawkins May 20, 2009 at 9:23 am

By now I’m sure you’ve discovered the small smoker boxes, both stainless steel and cast iron, that Lowe’s or Home Depot sell for around $10 that sit atop the burner of any gas grill. Kingsford also sells bags of wood “chips”, not chunks for sawdust, that is suitable for these shorter smoking chores of under 4-5 hours.

james October 16, 2009 at 10:22 am

I have a question for those who have done this process successfully. I just pulled my pork belly out of the fridge after 7 or 8 days of curing. One small piece was vaccumm sealed while the larger piece was ziplocked.
The piece that was sealed came out nice and pink in color as you would expect to see in store bought bacon. The larger piece of belly has a sort of brownish color to it like you’d see if the meat had almost spoiled or turned but it smells fine. I am drying in fridge for a day or so before smoking. Anyone experienced this brownish business? Is this a concern?

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: